Breaking News

Special report on AI in medical note-taking, how a hospital tackled tech literacy, & the battle for one-stop telehealth

March 28, 2023
Reporter, STAT Health Tech Writer
Good morning, health tech readers! My colleague Brittany Trang takes a close look at potential harms of medical notetaking technology guided by AI, and Ambar Castillo has a delightful and fascinating story about a Boston hospital that recognizes the impact language barriers and tech challenges can have on a person's health — and is actually doing something about them. And as employers and insurers tighten budgets, embattled industry veteran Teladoc is scrambling to make the case for its business.

Artificial intelligence

AI promises to revolutionize medical note taking. But at what cost?

AI_Clinical_Intelligence

Tech incumbents and startups alike are clamoring to apply artificial intelligence to medical documentation — a task that has long plagued clinicians burdened by hours of paperwork. But as the technology takes hold, concerns about harm and accuracy are mounting, Brittany reports in a sweeping new story. The industry is careening toward fully automated tools with less human oversight. Microsoft's Nuance, for instance, plans to blend large language model GPT-4 into a fully-AI driven medical scribe software called DAX, sidestepping the human reviewers that offered quality-control for its previous products. 

Brittany spoke to more than a dozen AI researchers, company executives, doctors, and quality documentation specialists to understand the chasm between what AI makers promise and the performance goals they'll have to meet if they're to be safely used in the clinic. A common concern: the technology isn't regulated by the FDA and is subject to little external accountability. 

"I do feel strongly that anything that is generated with solely AI should be labeled," Grace Cordovano, a longtime patient advocate, told STAT. "You go to Dunkin Donuts, there's a warning on your coffee cup saying 'this is hot.' Well, you know, obviously! So why are we not labeling? I just don't understand that." Read the full special report here.


hospitals

Not the geek squad

At a hospital in Lawrence, Mass., digital access coordinators like Janelle Vargas help patients access their electronic bills, medication lists, health records, and online Zoom appointments — crucial elements of modern health care that often exclude already medically underserved patients who don't speak English, or who can't navigate the technology on their phones. Ambar visited Pentucket Medical Riverwalk, part of the Mass General Brigham system, which is piloting the digital access coordinator program as part of Mass General's United Against Racism health equity initiative. 

Allison Bryant, the senior medical director for health equity at Mass General Brigham, told Ambar that "many of our patients have felt very comfortable that the DAC is someone who might look like their granddaughter or might be whomever else."

Ensuring that all patients get equitable access to technology requires careful attention to bias, Ambar reports: When front desk staff initially handed iPads out to patients to report their own health outcomes, they were lending the tablets out 20% less often to non-White patients, for instance. Patient portal engagement rates for Hispanic patients hovered at 4%at the beginning of the pandemic, though efforts like the digital access coordination pilot have bumped that number up beyond 15%. 

Read more about the pilot, and the patients it has touched, here.


Telehealth

How DEA's virtual care overhaul impacts psychiatrists

Federal laws threatening to restrict virtual prescriptions — especially for controlled substances — could turn telepsychiatry on its head, psychiatrist Jessica Gold writes in an opinion piece for STAT. 

The public health emergency will end in early May, and with it will go many regulatory flexibilities expanding reimbursement for virtual care. And though it had relaxed some of its restrictions on virtual controlled substance prescriptions during the emergency, the DEA recently proposed again requiring in-person visits for those prescriptions. 

Gold, who treat patients and prescribe medication for conditions like ADHD, said she's worried the new rules will keep some psychiatrists from seeing "this group of patients, so they don't have to bother with seeing anyone in person at all. For the rest of us, it will lead to an administrative disaster," she writes. Read more here, and let us know your thoughts.



Why telehealth point solutions might need a new strategy

As telehealth industry watchers predict even more consolidation over the next few quarters, and employers plan changes to vendor partnerships this year and next, virtual care companies are scrambling to pitch themselves as a one-stop shop for the spectrum of health care needs. The stakes are even higher as more than 40% of employers say they plan to change their contracts for point solutions addressing conditions like diabetes, musculoskeletal disease, and maternity and fertility care over the next two years, according to a WTW survey from last month. 

Teladoc is among companies attempting to position itself as a comprehensive platform, with services spanning primary care, urgent care, mental health and chronic care —  though skeptics have raised questions about whether it has meaningfully integrated chronic care business Livongo into its existing business, and whether its persistent impairment charges portend further struggles. 

Still, the company is promoting a peer-reviewed study conducted by Teladoc (the full results of which it plans to drop next month during a Society of Behavioral Medicine meeting) suggesting that patients enrolled in multiple integrated chronic care programs could help them manage their A1c, blood pressure and weight. We'll check back in late April on the rigor of the study and how much impact the results show. 

 

Also on telehealth…

Whole Foods co-founder and former CEO John Mackey's holistic care company Love.life — which boasts doctors who are experts in lifestyle medicine and nutrition — is acquiring another lifestyle medicine company called Plant Based Telehealth, the companies announced last week. They're rebranding as Love.Life Telehealth; users across the country can sign up for 30- or 60- minute appointments for $175 or $350. The service, like many of the direct-to-consumer telehealth companies we've seen cropping up, does not accept insurance.


industry news

Jobs and deals

  • At this year's ViVE conference in Nashville, Amazon Web Services launched a new health care accelerator focused on solving workforce issues including burnout. Among the 23 startups participating are Florence, Moonhub, and The TeleDentists
  • Health-related automation company Notable named James Lakes its new chief growth officer. Lakes was previously senior vice president of sales for health care providers at Salesforce.

More around STAT
Check out more exclusive coverage with a STAT+ subscription
Read premium in-depth biotech, pharma, policy, and life science coverage and analysis with all of our STAT+ articles.

What we're reading

  • Telehealth apps draw FTC crackdown, WSJ 
  • How Cigna rejects claims without reading them, ProPublica
  • A legal viewpoint on AI-generated medical advice, JAMA

Thanks for reading! More on Thursday - Mohana

Mohana Ravindranath is a Bay Area correspondent covering health tech at STAT and has made it her mission to separate out hype from reality in health care.


Enjoying STAT Health Tech? Tell us about your experience
Continue reading the latest health & science news with the STAT app
Download on the App Store or get it on Google Play
STAT
STAT, 1 Exchange Place, Boston, MA
©2023, All Rights Reserved.

No comments