Breaking News

Genentech's review of Tessier-Lavigne case, Wall Streets's reaction to Medicare Advantage rule, & CAR-T's effects on brain cancer

April 7, 2023
Reporter, Morning Rounds Writer
Good morning. First up, news on a Genentech review of scientific misconduct allegations, then two items about treating brain cancer and two more about deploying AI to understand two different diseases, including one item that touches on both.

science

Genentech: No evidence of fraud in Tessier-Lavigne paper but hints of misconduct by a lab postdoc

8634729050_c8bd1acff8_oAdam Fagen

Just yesterday morning we shared a special report about allegations of scientific misconduct by Stanford President Marc Tessier-Lavigne (above) during his academic and industry career. Hours later, Genentech said its internal review of allegations about a 2009 paper published by Tessier-Lavigne while he was a top executive at the biotech did not find evidence of fraud or intentional wrongdoing. But the review also hinted at previously undisclosed scientific misconduct by a post-doctoral researcher in Tessier-Lavigne's lab.

The company's five-page document notes none of the 35 current or former employees interviewed reported observing or knowing of fraud related to the 2009 study in Nature, whose lead author was a postdoc working for Tessier-Lavigne. But they struggled to reproduce the findings before and after they were published, and one senior Genentech person called for the paper to be retracted or corrected. Tessier-Lavigne's lawyer couldn't be immediately reached for comment. STAT's Jonathan Wosen has more.


insurance

Wall Street likes the delayed Medicare Advantage rule

The Biden administration's decision to delay some reforms to the Medicare Advantage program may have looked like it was buried late last Friday, but Wall Street happily awakened to it this week. Investors have raced to buy stocks of the largest Medicare Advantage insurers, including UnitedHealth, Humana, CVS Health, Elevance Health, and Centene, heartened by estimates that the health insurance companies could retain billions of extra taxpayer dollars next year. 

The slower rollout means they have more time to prepare for a new risk adjustment system that would attempt to address concerns that the government is overpaying these plans. As STAT's Bob Herman has reported, insurers have abused the system by exaggerating or making up people's diagnoses. Instead of switching over to a new system next year, everything will now be phased in over the next three years, according to the final regulation. Bob has more on the delay's implications.


health

To make immunotherapy safe for brain tumors, researchers must tackle new risks

The success of CAR-T immunotherapies in blood cancers has sparked hope for disarming other cancers. Brain cancer is a particularly tough target, one in need of new treatments and improvements in survival. Michelle Monje, a pediatric neuro-oncologist at Stanford, has led a trial of CAR-T targeting diffuse midline glioma, almost always fatal in young people. CAR-T worked against the tumors, Monje's team reports in Nature Medicine, but only after patients weathered inflammatory side effects more severe than the systemic toxic syndromes CAR-T is known for, stemming from supercharged immune activity.

"Purposefully inducing inflammation in the nervous system is a scary thing to do," Monje told STAT's Angus Chen. An expanding brain trapped in the skull can cause serious neurological symptoms, damage to vital structures, or death. Monje's team created a scale for what they named tumor inflammation-associated neurotoxicity to guide others working in a field still in its infancy. Read more.



Closer Look

A new AI tools promises mutation data to guide surgeons during brain surgery

adobe brainAdobe

In surgery to remove brain tumors, the Hippocratic oath imperative to "first, do no harm" is especially important, given the danger of damaging the patient's ability to walk or talk in an effort to remove all of the tumor. Without knowing what kind of tumor they're seeing, neurosurgeons can't be sure if it's better treated with chemo or radiation. Taking out a sliver of tissue for a quick biopsy still takes time to get results, so many patients return for a second surgery after a pathology report later. 

A tumor's genetics can be critical in guiding how aggressive a surgeon should be. A recent Nature study describes a tool that could potentially speed up that decision. A computer vision artificial intelligence-powered tool called DeepGlioma uses optical images of the tumor on a custom microscope slide, then takes only 90 seconds to give neurosurgeons data on genetic mutations during surgery. STAT's Brittany Trang has more, including caveats.


global health

Equatorial Guinea isn't letting WHO test Marburg vaccines and treatments

Here's an update from STAT's Helen Branswell: Equatorial Guinea has not yet agreed to allow the WHO to conduct clinical trials of Marburg virus vaccines and therapeutics, the global health agency said yesterday. There are no approved vaccines or drugs for Marburg, which is related to the viruses that cause Ebola. To date there have been 14 confirmed and 23 probable cases in this outbreak; at least 33 people have died.

Abdi Mahamud, WHO's acting director of alert and response coordination, said the government has said it is currently focused on building up contact tracing and other key elements of the outbreak response and may allow clinical trials later. Marburg outbreaks — the only opportunity to test whether experimental vaccines and drugs work — have been rare in recent years, and groups developing vaccines are keen for the opportunity to see if they are protective. There is currently another smaller Marburg outbreak ongoing in Tanzania, but there have been no new cases recently.

Yesterday the CDC sent an alert to U.S. health care providers, warning them that while the risk of imported cases appears low, they should be on the lookout for possible cases.


chronic disease

Liver researchers look to AI to better study a complex disease

People often don't know they have NASH and doctors don't know exactly what causes it. NASH, or nonalcoholic steatohepatitis, is a liver disease that some experts believe affects a quarter of U.S. adults. Marked by scarring of liver tissue, it's a complex disease that can lead to end-stage liver disease. There are no FDA-approved drugs to treat it, but dozens are being tested in clinical trials. 

Here's the problem doctors and scientists aired at a recent conference in LA: They don't know which of multiple factors is the most important driver of the disease, so it's hard to pick patient characteristics to study. A new possible solution: AI, which could sort through gene expression or microscopic observations from biopsies or clinical features to identify patterns a doctor might miss. STAT's Isabella Cueto has more on how that might help, including companies involved in the pursuit.


More around STAT
Check out more exclusive coverage with a STAT+ subscription
Read premium in-depth biotech, pharma, policy, and life science coverage and analysis with all of our STAT+ articles.

What we're reading

  • Abbott recalls 4 million glucose monitor readers over risk they can catch fire, STAT
  • Scientists turned monkey stem cells into 'synthetic embryos,' Wired
  • FDA withdraws approval of controversial drug to prevent preterm births, STAT
  • Assisted-living homes are rejecting Medicaid and evicting seniors, Washington Post

  • Brazilian committee says a Vertex cystic fibrosis is not cost-effective and should not be reimbursed, STAT

Thanks for reading! More Monday,


Enjoying Morning Rounds? Tell us about your experience
Continue reading the latest health & science news with the STAT app
Download on the App Store or get it on Google Play
STAT
STAT, 1 Exchange Place, Boston, MA
©2023, All Rights Reserved.

No comments