Breaking News

The War on Recovery: How the U.S. is sabotaging its best tools to prevent overdose deaths

March 5, 2024
Reporter, Morning Rounds Writer
Good morning. Today we bring you Part 1 of the War on Recovery, Lev Facher's yearlong investigation into how the U.S. denies lifesaving medications to people with opioid addiction.

STAT investigation

The war on recovery: How the U.S. attacks the best weapon we have against opioid deathsSTAT24_OpioidCrisis_Fin01-V2

Thumy Phan for STAT

They are not perfect, but they are the best tools we have: Methadone and buprenorphine are highly effective at preventing overdose deaths. They're cheap, they're easy to use, and they work. But these drugs, forever tarnished by a former head of Health and Human Services calling their use "just substituting one opioid for another," reach barely one-fifth of the roughly 2.5 million Americans with opioid use disorder. That means tens of thousands have died for lack of it, blocked by stigma and barriers to access.

This failure is an active choice, STAT's Lev Facher learned in a yearlong investigation. Virtually every sector of American society is obstructing the use of medications that could prevent tens of thousands of deaths each year. That includes Narcotics Anonymous, rehab facilities and sober living houses, regulators of the trucking and airline industries, and medical boards that restrict doctors and nurses in recovery from taking the drugs they'd prescribe to patients for opioid addiction.

"We have a tool, medication-assisted treatment, that we know dramatically reduces overdose deaths," said David Frank, a medical sociologist at New York University who is in recovery from opioid addiction and takes methadone. "But because it's so difficult to access, people that could and should be alive continue to die."

"

"I estimate that we would have at least 50% less people dying, and that's conservative. I think it would probably be much more consequential."

Nora Volkow
director of the National Institute on Drug Abuse

Instead, we have painful and ineffective "detox," horseback riding, or 12-step approaches.  

"While such programs rely heavily on hope, mindfulness, and religion, they often ignore the physiological realities of addiction — in particular, the debilitating withdrawal that occurs when regular opioid users attempt to suddenly stop," Lev writes. "In any other medical field, favoring prayer over proven medication would be considered malpractice. Yet for addiction treatment in the U.S., it's simply the way things work."

Read more about how the two medications work, how hard they are to get, and what other countries do to enlist them in recovery. Lev quotes Kurt Cobain and Alex Hogan's video explains the nightmarish reality of withdrawal. Don't miss Lev's Q&A with Nora Volkow, who has been director of the National Institute on Drug Abuse since 2003. 


covid's long tail

Large study finds the risk of an autoimmune disease rises after Covid infection, but wanes

In yet another impact of Covid-19, infection with the virus appears to raise the risk of developing an autoimmune disease, a large study from South Korea and Japan suggests. The paper, published yesterday in the Annals of Internal Medicine, found that among 22 million people studied from 2020 through 2022, there was a 25% greater risk among those infected vs. not infected of developing such autoimmune diseases as rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, Sjögren syndrome, mixed connective tissue disease, and vasculitis. Compared to people who had contracted the flu, the Covid risk for autoimmune illnesses was 30% higher.

The researchers did find that being vaccinated against Covid lowered the risk of developing an autoimmune inflammatory rheumatic disease, possibly because vaccination protected them from more severe disease. And the risk dissipated in the year after Covid infection, raising questions about whether what looks like autoimmune disease is a temporary flare of the immune system. STAT's Isabella Cueto has more.


health

How infant mortality rates vary by race and other characteristicsScreenshot 2024-03-04 at 3.36.28 PM

NCHS / CDC

Infant mortality grew by 3% in 2022, the biggest increase in 20 years, the CDC reported in November. Now, a new analysis led by the same researcher looks at how rising rates vary across race and Hispanic origin, combined with certain maternal characteristics.

Mortality rates in the first year of life continue to be higher for infants born to American Indian and Alaska Native women and to Black women, while they are lower for Asian women. Overall, mortality rates were highest among infants of women with obesity, women who smoked, women who received the WIC nutrition benefit, women who began prenatal care later in pregnancy, and women covered by Medicaid. There were some differences:

  • Infants of white women who received WIC had higher mortality rates than infants of white women who did not receive WIC. The opposite was true for infants of Black and Hispanic women. 
  • The percentage of women with obesity was higher among American Indian and Alaska Native and Black women than other groups.

"Some of these characteristics can be used as proxies for societal inequities by race," the authors conclude.



in the lab

In a first, scientists generate fetal-cell organoids from amniotic fluidAdobeStock_595595733

Adobe 

There's genetic material floating around a fetus in the bath we call amniotic fluid, some of it offering clues to diagnose disease after being extracted by a needle in amniocentesis during pregnancy. For research purposes, scientists have turned to postmortem fetal tissue to create lab models called organoids, but that process arouses controversy. Now there may be another way, incorporating some of each method. Researchers report in Nature Medicine on their early success pulling some live cells from amniotic fluid and growing three-dimensional organoids — miniature lung, kidney, and small intestines — from them.

They hope to develop a new tool to study and diagnose congenital fetal diseases based on the progenitor cells drawn during amniocentesis or other prenatal diagnostic procedures. "For the first time, we can actually access the fetus without touching the fetus," Mattia Gerli, first author of the paper, said during a press briefing. STAT's Deborah Balthazar explains.


health inequity

Medical debt can be deadly for 'a new type of underclass,' study finds 

Add medical debt to the social determinants of health in the U.S., a new JAMA Network Open study suggests. Looking at 2018 data in nearly 3,000 U.S. counties to see how medical debt  — bills more than six months overdue and in the hands of a collections agency — correlated with population health, the researchers found health did suffer the most where medical debt was highest. (They chose a pre-Covid time period to avoid pandemic confounding.)

On average, just under 20% of the population in a county had medical debt in collections. In counties with higher rates of medical debt, people reported more days when they were physically or mentally unwell. Medical debt also tracked with mortality rates for some of the leading causes of death — heart disease, cancer, and suicide — and with geography. States with the most medical debt were Texas, Louisiana, Georgia, Tennessee, South Carolina, North Carolina, and West Virginia. "We have created a new type of underclass, the medical debtor," a companion editorial says.


More around STAT
Check out more exclusive coverage with a STAT+ subscription
Read premium in-depth biotech, pharma, policy, and life science coverage and analysis with all of our STAT+ articles.

What we're reading

  • Your child's medicine probably wasn't fully vetted. Here's why, Undark

  • What science says about hybrid working — and how to make it a success, Nature
  • White House is told the big three PBMs are 'everything wrong with this industry,' STAT
  • 'It's a nightmare': One of the most common children's asthma meds is no longer available, leaving families scrambling, Boston Globe
  • First over-the-counter birth control pill in U.S. begins shipping to stores,  Associated Press

Thanks for reading! More tomorrow,


Enjoying Morning Rounds? Tell us about your experience
Continue reading the latest health & science news with the STAT app
Download on the App Store or get it on Google Play
STAT
STAT, 1 Exchange Place, Boston, MA
©2024, All Rights Reserved.

No comments