Breaking News

Trust me, I’m (not?) a doctor

September 29, 2024
avatar-torie-bosch
First Opinion editor

Last weekend, I did one of my favorite things: I went to see a movie by myself. I had to choose between "My Old Ass," in which a teenager tripping on mushrooms meets her 39-year-old future self, and "Speak No Evil," a horror film based on a Danish movie by the same name. Somehow, "Speak No Evil" seemed less scary to me at this moment of my life, so that's what I went with. It was a good choice: tense, tight, not (too) gory. 

It also left me thinking about the trust we put in doctors. In "Speak No Evil," an American couple and their child vacationing in Italy meet an Irish family of three. The American parents are wary of the Irish adults, who come on pretty strong. But they visibly relax when the Irish father, played by an alarmingly buff James McAvoy, says he's a doctor, offhandedly mentioning his volunteer work with Medicines Sans Frontières. Soon they are spending every day of vacation together — and months later, the Americans decide to visit their new friends in Ireland. Finding out their host may not actually be a physician is one of the most jarring early warning signs to the Americans — though they continue to make bad decisions typical for characters in a horror movie.

I think that speaks (forgive me) to the way those of us without an M.D. or D.O. (or, heck, D.D.M. or D.V.M.) think about doctors: that they must be of good character, that they must be rich enough to comfortably house three guests, that you are physically and emotionally safe with them. Good thing? Bad thing? Depends on the doctor, I suppose — but loved seeing a horror movie twist that trust around.

This week on First Opinion: The U.N. General Assembly this week featured a high-level meeting on antimicrobial resistance. Ahead of the meeting, Scott Weese, a veterinarian who is active in combatting antimicrobial resistance, wrote about the need to address inappropriate use of antibiotics in animals

After the meeting, WHO Director General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus took to First Opinion to celebrate what he called "a major new political declaration to radically scale up efforts to combat antimicrobial resistance," approved unanimously by U.N. member countries. He wrote, "I see this declaration as a strong signal from countries that they are committed to addressing this global threat."

Meanwhile, as H5N1 continues its worrying spread, Ranu Dhillon, Abraar Karan, and Devabhaktuni Srikrishna propose one way to get better data: sequence wastewater material as close as possible to dairy farms. Speaking of infectious disease: a pediatrician writes about his mother's bout with West Nile virus, which came with a most alarming symptom.

And in D.C.-related opeds: new Health and Human Services rules can't touch the primary reason for the current outbreak of research misconduct; the need to reauthorize — and expand — the Older Americans Act to keep seniors safe from extreme heat; how the next president can reform Medicare; how to fix the collection of data about Americans with disabilities; and why Hatch-Waxman is in the grips of a midlife crisis (welcome to the club). 

Recommendation of the week: Who doesn't love a good mystery? Read STAT's Rachel Cohrs Zhang on the anti-pharma bus touring swing states and others with contentious elections. Who's paying for the bus? Well, that's the mystery. 

Courtesy TBIJ/BSAC/Khaula Jamil

WHO director general: A breakthrough global agreement on combatting antimicrobial resistance

Antimicrobial resistance is associated with more than 1 million deaths a year, with many more projected over the coming decades.

By Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus


Sequencing wastewater material may be the key to getting a grip on the H5N1 bird flu outbreak

A lack of testing has made it difficult to know where H5N1 is circulating. Sampling and sequencing wasterwater by dairy farms could help.

By Ranu Dhillon, Abraar Karan, and Devabhaktuni Srikrishna


Congress must reauthorize the Older Americans Act to keep seniors safe from heat

If Congress doesn't finalize an extension for the Older Americans Act by the end of September, critical services will be threatened.

By Marquisha Johns and Casey Doherty



ALASTAIR PIKE/AFP via Getty Images

Veterinary medicine is key to overcoming antimicrobial resistance

Veterinary medicine needs international guidance on appropriate antibiotic use, just like we have for human medicine.

By Scott Weese


How the next president should reform Medicare

Medicare Advantage has lived up to its name for millions of retirees. But now it requires a thorough, competition-based overhaul.

By Paul Ginsburg and Steve Lieberman


Millions of people are missing from U.S. disability data

Federal surveys focus on limitations on specific tasks, missing many with mental illness, chronic health conditions, and more.

By Bonnielin Swenor, Scott Landes, and Jean Hall


Colorized transmission electron micrograph of a West Nile virus particle (orange) found within the cytoplasm of a cell (magenta).
NIAID/Wikimedia Commons

What happened when my mother became the first 2024 West Nile patient in Manhattan

When my mother came down with the rare West Nile virus, the worst part was her sudden alienation from herself.

By Christopher Hartnick


STAT+ | 40 doesn't look good on Hatch-Waxman

On the Hatch-Waxman Act's 40th anniversary, it's time to examine its legacy and what it actually gave us: the world's highest drug prices.

By Tahir Amin and Timi Iwayemi


New HHS rules can't address the primary reason for research misconduct

None of the proposed solutions for research misconduct address the root cause: the immense pressure to publish, publish, publish.

By Paul Martin Jensen


More around STAT
Check out more exclusive coverage with a STAT+ subscription
Read premium in-depth biotech, pharma, policy, and life science coverage and analysis with all of our STAT+ articles.

Enjoying First Opinion? Tell us about your experience
Continue reading the latest health & science news with the STAT app
Download on the App Store or get it on Google Play
STAT
STAT, 1 Exchange Place, Boston, MA
©2024, All Rights Reserved.

No comments